Debate Evaluation Forms

Teams

Pro Con
Logan Jason
Josh Luke

Argument

Affirmative Statement It is unethical for individuals to consume essential but scarce resources at a rate significantly higher than can maintained for the entire population of the planet.
Negative Statement It is ethical for some individuals to consume essential but scarce resources significantly faster than can be maintained everyone under certain circumstances

Debate Format
Activity Time
Pro side Argument 10
Con side Argument 10
Team Rebuttal Conference 10
Pro Rebuttal 4
Con Rebuttal 4
Pro Summation 2
Con Summation 2

Form
  • Visual (distracting movements, posture, eye contact, audio-visuals, etc.)
  • Auditory (distracting use of voice, speed of delivery, etc.)
  • Creativity in presenting defense.
  • Use of handouts and/or PowerPoint Slides
  • Keeps to time limits.
Clarity
  • Stating ideas clearly.
  • Well organized presentation.
Arguments for Position
  • Connection of premises to conclusion.
  • Likely truth of premises.
Objections to Opponents’ Arguments
  • Care with which the opponents’ arguments are undermined.
  • Vigor in undermining the opponents’ position.
Sources
  • Appropriate use of references (articles, texts, etc.)
  • Number of references

Assessment Team well
done
15
little
deficiency
13
some
deficiency
11
average
deficiency
9
significant
deficiency
7
comment
Form Pro X          
  Con X          
Clarity Pro X         Well done
  Con X         Good work
Arguments for Position Pro X         some important claims are unreferenced
  Con X        

Also some unreference points

Some interesting points

Objections to Opponents' Arguments Pro X          
  Con X          
Sources Pro X          
  Con X          
Pro Total   75          
Con Total   75          
Topic revision: r2 - 2014-04-16 - JimSkon
 
This site is powered by the TWiki collaboration platformCopyright &© by the contributing authors. All material on this collaboration platform is the property of the contributing authors.
Ideas, requests, problems regarding TWiki? Send feedback